179,854Messages
9,130Senders
30Years
342mboxes

← back to listing · view thread

From:
Greg Earle
To:
Cc:
Date:
Thu, 10 Oct 1996 11:08:57 -0700
Subject:
(idm) Divas: Just Say No (Was: Re: Jungle/Drum n Bass)
Msg-Id:
<9610101809.AA27221@isolar.Tujunga.CA.US>
In-Reply-To:
<199610101601.RAA28513@miranda.>
Mbox:
idm.9610.gz
quoted 5 lines JUST SAY NO TO DIVAS !!!!>> JUST SAY NO TO DIVAS !!!! > > I'm confused. When you say diva's do you mean all singers, or > just female ones, or just singers you don't like? Do you like > any music with vocals? Thats a bit extreme if you don't -
Is it?
quoted 1 line Personally I reckon a bit of singing often does wonders for a track> Personally I reckon a bit of singing often does wonders for a track
I don't.
quoted 1 line i.e. The two Chameleon tracks on Good Looking, erm and loads> i.e. The two Chameleon tracks on Good Looking, erm and loads
Chameleon, blecch ... I can see why khannan suntharam said what he did ... I've heard a few Goldie tracks that made me think to myself, "Hmmn, some nice noises in here ... " and then some vocal comes along and suddenly the snares-that-never-stop of Jungle combined with the vocals just puts me right off of it.
quoted 4 lines What do other IDM'ers think of singing on electronic music? I certainly know> What do other IDM'ers think of singing on electronic music? I certainly know > a few people, who having discovered a world outside guitar/bass/drums/vocals > bounce violently in the opposite direction and can't stand any hint of > a vocal. Oh well - their loss.
Vocals suck. Hehehe hehe hehehehe ... If I wanted vocals, I'd sing Joy Division songs in the shower ... (But seriously folks) I don't mind when a vocal snippet is used as an instrumental addition - the odd Ofra Haza sample here and there, fer example, or the Karen Carpenter motif from "No One In The World" - but I have little tolerance for singing or House divas (outside of the club/rave environment). Being one of those people who's been pummeled for the past 30 years by guitar/bass/drums/vocals and who "bounce[d] violently in the opposite direction", I resent the implication that it's "my loss" because I'm sick of conventional music and vocals. Whatever floats yer boat mate ... - Greg