179,854Messages
9,130Senders
30Years
342mboxes

← archive index

[idm] Confusion on the grandest scale

6 messages · 6 participants · spans 2 days · search this subject
2000-06-20 14:16[idm] Confusion on the grandest scale
2000-06-20 19:21Re: [idm] Confusion on the grandest scale
2000-06-21 13:38christopher [idm] re: Confusion on the grandest scale
2000-06-21 21:06emmett Re: [idm] re: Confusion on the grandest scale
2000-06-21 21:14William Samuels Re: [idm] re: Confusion on the grandest scale
2000-06-22 14:07Kelley Hackett RE: [idm] Confusion on the grandest scale
expand allcollapse allclick any summary to toggle that message
2000-06-20 14:16hardbarker@hotmail.comI have finally found the confidence after the sort time I have been on this list to ask yo
From:
To:
Date:
Tue, 20 Jun 2000 15:16:05 +0100
Subject:
[idm] Confusion on the grandest scale
permalink · <B5718489.545%hardbarker@hotmail.com>
I have finally found the confidence after the sort time I have been on this list to ask you all collectively for any insights you all may have on something that has had me vexed for quite a while now. This list is a great deal more international than I had at first imagined. I had always seen IDM as a predominantly British thing, because (and I mean nothing by this) the majority of IDM musicians and labels are located here in the UK. And yet, imagine my surprise when I see so many acts playing over in America, and so many independent club nights and radio shows playing a high quality mix of electronic music. When I first experienced IDM in a live scenario, I saw LFO and Autechre play at Sankeys about 5 or 6 years ago. The place was packed, and the atmosphere was like nothing else. All of us were there for a unified moment, we all managed to capture something together, brought into one place because of our love and respect for the music being played (anyone remember "Flutter" at the end, ask me about it some time!) Now, I go to events whenever I can, and am met with nothing but chin-stroking and elitism. Went to Leeds and saw the Skam crew rip it up, and yet no-one danced. Me and two friends boogied for hours, looking like twats (and we were met with that attitude in a very upfront manner), yet to be honest with you I had no choice........I could not and did not sit down to such a high quality set of such excellent music. And then Autechre play in Manchester, and when they do they are greeted by more standing around and, to be honest, a sense of elitism rather then community. No wonder they are spending so much time in America.(sorry, that was a little agressive, but I feel very passionately about this) With nights that get on average 100 people through the door, there is no money in promoting IDM. And yet we all know how fanatical the average IDM fan is about his/her music. So where does the gap come from? Why (in my experience) does there seem to be no scene with which I can immerse myself in Either I am missing something, or you guys need to ewxplain to me why even in Manchester, home to so much IDM, there is still no scene? Someone educate me before I explode. I am particularly intersted in the American point of view, because you guys seem to be a great deal closer to my ideal of a scene that anything over here. Yours MattC
2000-06-20 19:21Magicnerd8@aol.comIn a message dated 06/20/2000 3:16:57 PM GMT Daylight Time, hardbarker@hotmail.com writes:
From:
To:
,
Date:
Tue, 20 Jun 2000 15:21:45 EDT
Subject:
Re: [idm] Confusion on the grandest scale
permalink · <61.4aa91b4.26811e49@aol.com>
In a message dated 06/20/2000 3:16:57 PM GMT Daylight Time, hardbarker@hotmail.com writes: << With nights that get on average 100 people through the door, there is no money in promoting IDM. And yet we all know how fanatical the average IDM fan is about his/her music. So where does the gap come from? Why (in my experience) does there seem to be no scene with which I can immerse myself in Either I am missing something, or you guys need to ewxplain to me why even in Manchester, home to so much IDM, there is still no scene? Someone educate me before I explode. I am particularly intersted in the American point of view, because you guys seem to be a great deal closer to my ideal of a scene that anything over here.>>> Yeah, I see that a lot, personally I interpret it as protectionism and not really elitism. More than likely, IDMers connect dancing with raves and (as seen recently), raving with foolishness. Indeed, dancing invites power plays, attention-drawing and all sorts of competition. Frustrating and annoying it can be. I'm rather tired of "circles" and battles, sometimes I'm just there to relax. Los Angeles is rather this way, even at dirty breaknoise shows, no one really shakes that ass. If people aren't dancing, go ahead and start. I mean, don't see it as some sort of make or break situation where you MUST dance to piss on the elitists, but if you feel somethin, just pump that ass. aaaaaaahhhhh, Jon np: Fuckhead (Mego) - Uh?! Satan through the machine! --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: idm-unsubscribe@hyperreal.org For additional commands, e-mail: idm-help@hyperreal.org
2000-06-21 13:38christopheryou says, > no dancing, no scene in UK. US has got it tho eh? no, it's the same way over h
From:
christopher
To:
,
Date:
Wed, 21 Jun 2000 06:38:22 -0700 (PDT)
Subject:
[idm] re: Confusion on the grandest scale
permalink · <20000621133822.9975.qmail@web108.yahoomail.com>
you says,
quoted 1 line no dancing, no scene in UK. US has got it tho eh?> no dancing, no scene in UK. US has got it tho eh?
no, it's the same way over here. no one really dances. over here it may be because of lacking comprehension more than elitism though. at recent muziq/hrvatski/eoss show no one would dance until vatski whipped out the disco-like track at the end (remix of amen brother?) and when muziq turned into full on hardcore bmbmbmbmbm for over half an hour. in both they could understand the bmbmbmbm. the breakbeats are too confusing - "what beat is coming next? not sure, better not move or i'll mess it up." probably similar for nonbreakbeaty music. if it's got a groove, like these guys or skam, i don't see what the problem is. of course people could just be really enjoying listening to it rather than getting all into it physically. nothing wrong with that eh? i imagine it'd get a bit boring sitting motionless and attentive for hours though. ===== __________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Send instant messages with Yahoo! Messenger. http://im.yahoo.com/ --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: idm-unsubscribe@hyperreal.org For additional commands, e-mail: idm-help@hyperreal.org
2000-06-21 21:06emmetthmmm...I'll pipe in, in defense of the los angeles area. at least at the few idm-ish shows
From:
emmett
To:
Date:
Wed, 21 Jun 2000 13:06:01 -0800
Subject:
Re: [idm] re: Confusion on the grandest scale
permalink · <20000621200752.DDYD6703.lh2.rdc1.sdca.home.com@[24.0.179.89]>
hmmm...I'll pipe in, in defense of the los angeles area. at least at the few idm-ish shows that I've attended, I was pleasantly surprised at how many people were dancing. both times that I've seen phoenecia (in LA), I didn't get the feeling that very many people thought they were too cool to boogie. but hey, if you can sit still through one of phoenecia's live sets, then I'd think you were putting effort into *not* getting your groove on! but I remember reading reviews of the same or similar bills hitting other cities in other states, and being surprised that nobody danced. em. ----------
quoted 5 lines From: christopher <gravavarez@yahoo.com>>From: christopher <gravavarez@yahoo.com> >To: hardbarker@hotmail.com, idm@hyperreal.org >Subject: [idm] re: Confusion on the grandest scale >Date: Wed, Jun 21, 2000, 5:38 AM >
quoted 29 lines you says,> you says, >> no dancing, no scene in UK. US has got it tho eh? > > no, it's the same way over here. no one really dances. over here it may be > because of lacking comprehension more than elitism though. at recent > muziq/hrvatski/eoss show no one would dance until vatski whipped out the > disco-like track at the end (remix of amen brother?) and when muziq turned > into full on hardcore bmbmbmbmbm for over half an hour. in both they could > understand the bmbmbmbm. the breakbeats are too confusing - "what beat is > coming next? not sure, better not move or i'll mess it up." probably similar > for nonbreakbeaty music. if it's got a groove, like these guys or skam, i > don't see what the problem is. > > of course people could just be really enjoying listening to it rather than > getting all into it physically. nothing wrong with that eh? i imagine it'd > get a bit boring sitting motionless and attentive for hours though. > > ===== > > > __________________________________________________ > Do You Yahoo!? > Send instant messages with Yahoo! Messenger. > http://im.yahoo.com/ > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- > To unsubscribe, e-mail: idm-unsubscribe@hyperreal.org > For additional commands, e-mail: idm-help@hyperreal.org >
--------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: idm-unsubscribe@hyperreal.org For additional commands, e-mail: idm-help@hyperreal.org
2000-06-21 21:14William Samuels--- emmett <emmett9@home.com> wrote: > hmmm...I'll pipe in, in defense of the los angeles
From:
William Samuels
To:
emmett ,
Date:
Wed, 21 Jun 2000 14:14:54 -0700 (PDT)
Subject:
Re: [idm] re: Confusion on the grandest scale
permalink · <20000621211454.28862.qmail@web2103.mail.yahoo.com>
--- emmett <emmett9@home.com> wrote:
quoted 18 lines hmmm...I'll pipe in, in defense of the los angeles> hmmm...I'll pipe in, in defense of the los angeles > area. at least at the few > idm-ish shows that I've attended, I was pleasantly > surprised at how many > people were dancing. > both times that I've seen phoenecia (in LA), I > didn't get the feeling that > very many people thought they were too cool to > boogie. but hey, if you can > sit still through one of phoenecia's live sets, then > I'd think you were > putting effort into *not* getting your groove on! > but I remember reading reviews of the same or > similar bills hitting other > cities in other states, and being surprised that > nobody danced. > > em.
When I bumped into Autechre at the Ihop on Sunset Blvd, (back in 95 I'm guessing) they seemed a little disappointed that more people weren't dancing. It surprised me because it seemed like the whole crowd was dancing to me...especially to Second Bad Vilbel. I guess they expected more. Mark Broom had some people moving. __________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Send instant messages with Yahoo! Messenger. http://im.yahoo.com/ --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: idm-unsubscribe@hyperreal.org For additional commands, e-mail: idm-help@hyperreal.org
2000-06-22 14:07Kelley HackettI will chime in sense I have been getting out a little more.... Hmmm, First, we should all
From:
Kelley Hackett
To:
,
Date:
Thu, 22 Jun 2000 09:07:29 -0500
Subject:
RE: [idm] Confusion on the grandest scale
permalink · <397CA68ABF5AD111863C00805F0DDE981386E4@aba.iupui.edu>
I will chime in sense I have been getting out a little more.... Hmmm, First, we should all quit the elitist stuff....I mean, do U guys really care what another thinks? Well I dont, besides U cant change the way that somebody thinks....unless you have one of those old Frankenstein brain things, ha ha, or you own the Medium by which ideas are given(Umm can someone say TV)....still...I will stop trippn.... When at the Vinyl in NYC, man, even if U R standing...U gotta be having a good time...the music is just too darn happening.....if I was the only person dancing with a nice fine female, umm, I would have no complaints........in fact, I am so silly--bold--and nutty---I'd be looking at the other cats hanging on the wall while dancing ecstatically with her yelling are U guys nutz....look at this mutha.......Eeee gads.......... Planet K in mind(Manchester).......there felt to be a scene to me...I mean, there I danced with this female who, from all appearances looked like she was from Italy---slim---another Egads, but ahhh....Everyone was dancing....and it was really my first time at an event like that.....A great time. My thing is this, with the entire thread Matt, U have to make stuff happen...Dont wait around like them and say who is going to dance first. Of course u didnt, and typically for me when I just let my self go, then I have the best time ever(and TYPICALLY I DONT DANCE). The DEMF, I didnt dance once, but watching this sister who danced the whole time, and the crowd in general..........I had the best time Ever! np) Juan Atkins, Convextion(ahhhh Techno) Hk! -----Original Message----- From: hardbarker@hotmail.com [mailto:hardbarker@hotmail.com] Sent: Tuesday, June 20, 2000 9:16 AM To: idm@hyperreal.org Subject: [idm] Confusion on the grandest scale I have finally found the confidence after the sort time I have been on this list to ask you all collectively for any insights you all may have on something that has had me vexed for quite a while now. This list is a great deal more international than I had at first imagined. I had always seen IDM as a predominantly British thing, because (and I mean nothing by this) the majority of IDM musicians and labels are located here in the UK. And yet, imagine my surprise when I see so many acts playing over in America, and so many independent club nights and radio shows playing a high quality mix of electronic music. When I first experienced IDM in a live scenario, I saw LFO and Autechre play at Sankeys about 5 or 6 years ago. The place was packed, and the atmosphere was like nothing else. All of us were there for a unified moment, we all managed to capture something together, brought into one place because of our love and respect for the music being played (anyone remember "Flutter" at the end, ask me about it some time!) Now, I go to events whenever I can, and am met with nothing but chin-stroking and elitism. Went to Leeds and saw the Skam crew rip it up, and yet no-one danced. Me and two friends boogied for hours, looking like twats (and we were met with that attitude in a very upfront manner), yet to be honest with you I had no choice........I could not and did not sit down to such a high quality set of such excellent music. And then Autechre play in Manchester, and when they do they are greeted by more standing around and, to be honest, a sense of elitism rather then community. No wonder they are spending so much time in America.(sorry, that was a little agressive, but I feel very passionately about this) With nights that get on average 100 people through the door, there is no money in promoting IDM. And yet we all know how fanatical the average IDM fan is about his/her music. So where does the gap come from? Why (in my experience) does there seem to be no scene with which I can immerse myself in Either I am missing something, or you guys need to ewxplain to me why even in Manchester, home to so much IDM, there is still no scene? Someone educate me before I explode. I am particularly intersted in the American point of view, because you guys seem to be a great deal closer to my ideal of a scene that anything over here. Yours MattC --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: idm-unsubscribe@hyperreal.org For additional commands, e-mail: idm-help@hyperreal.org