my god... totally ignore my post below. that was complete ass. eww.
-mark
Mark wrote:
quoted 49 lines esa ruoho wrote:> esa ruoho wrote:
>
>>
>> to see him finally putting out a debut ep and a debut lp, and then
>> seeing both of them absolutely ravaged by loose-gun reviewers, to see
>> him absolutely ignored and shunned as an autechre/plaid/boc copycat
>> (which he is not.end of discussion) and then there's people on here
>> that want him dropped from warp?? what the fuck are you people on?
>> do you even want to listen to music?
>
>
> I certainly see signs of being derivative. Doesn't make me right or
> wrong, though. That's how i see it, and it's not like I've jumped the
> gun, I've listened to Qtio, and ESPECIALLY claro dozens of times.
> There's some sweet tunes on it. It certainly forge new passageways
> into music and sound, though. The structures, melodies, and textures
> are all very rehashed. He may not intentionally copycatting, but
> through simple osmosis and picking and choosing what he likes through
> his influences, it comes off that way to me. sorry. and i'm sober,
> btw. and i listen to a lot of music, including yours (which i'll
> admit, you have more originality in style than brothomstates, easy).
>
> on a good note, there's a really nice track on the penguin mechanics
> vol 3 by brothomstates, called "not kava" I think. one of his better
> songs.
>
>>
>> theres people out there who are very, _very_ glad to see him on warp,
>> and look forward to hearing any new brothomstates, and then there's
>> people who have somehow acquired the grand knowledge that leads them
>> into the epic conclusion of him being a worthless derivative copycat.
>
>
> its a subjective issue. you're not necessarily right if theres a lot
> of people in the other camp. and neither am i.
>
>>
>> shame on you lot.
>>
> hey now. do i have to like every frickin' artist on warp? is every
> human being who spits out IDM untouchable to criticism? i think not.
>
> =mark
>
>
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
> To unsubscribe, e-mail: idm-unsubscribe@hyperreal.org
> For additional commands, e-mail: idm-help@hyperreal.org
>
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: idm-unsubscribe@hyperreal.org
For additional commands, e-mail: idm-help@hyperreal.org