179,854Messages
9,130Senders
30Years
342mboxes

← archive index

(idm) REVIEW: "From Within 2" Namlook/Hawtin

2 messages · 2 participants · spans 1 day · search this subject
1995-11-01 16:13Temporary Insanity (idm) REVIEW: "From Within 2" Namlook/Hawtin
└─ 1995-11-01 18:28Harvey Thornburg Re: (idm) REVIEW: "From Within 2" Namlook/Hawtin
expand allcollapse allclick any summary to toggle that message
1995-11-01 16:13Temporary InsanityFrom Within 2 (FAX PW 22) Richie Hawtin/Peter Namlook I've actually fallen off on my FAX b
From:
Temporary Insanity
To:
, , ,
Date:
Wed, 1 Nov 1995 10:13:51 -0600
Subject:
(idm) REVIEW: "From Within 2" Namlook/Hawtin
permalink · <9511011013.ZM17467@elvis.cadsi.com>
From Within 2 (FAX PW 22) Richie Hawtin/Peter Namlook I've actually fallen off on my FAX buying of late -- this is the first one I've bought in a couple of months, primarily because there's such a thing as having enough of a particular style of music. But, I'm a Hawtin fan and a Namlook fan (so sue me). I haven't found the first "From Within" so I jumped on this one. It's been on constant rotation at work here for a day or two and my impression is: meditative, smooth, harmonically interesting. The first track "Do Bassdrums have Feelings" starts out with a neo-classical rubato section, complete with ahh-chorus, before going into a more rhythmic section based around a nice little one measure groove. Then you get a percussive section with rising and falling sub-bass that would be deadly on the bins. In my opinion this is not one of those "doesn't go anywhere" tracks people slag FAX for. This one covers some ground and has a sort of pleasantness and harmonic interest you don't often find, impeccably sequenced to rise and fall in intensity. 'Brain to Midi' is more in deep chill territory, starting out with quiet ring modulated speach sounds and distant rumbling. Eventually a solo synth comes in and meanders about pleasantly, to be joined by a one measure bassline pattern. It's a kind of long jam on a spanish-sounding modal scale. Finally about 13 minutes you finally get a little of Richie's Devilfish 303, and then it's gone again almost as quickly. It's as well structured as 'Bass Drum' but it's not as immediately inviting. And the name is something of a misnomer, as the piece sounds like it was mostly done with analog-style sequencers and live playing. There is such a thing as a brainwave-to-midi convertor, but I seriously doubt they used it here. 'Future Surfacing (What Lies Ahead)' is somewhat mistitled as well, it sounds a lot more like an early Tangerine Dream piece than anything 'futuristic' Again we get a combination of pattern sequencing with solos from Namlook. The pleasures here come from slow introduction of one-bar melodic loops in counterpoint over the course of the piece. Well into the piece comes a nicely syncopated 909 pattern. And then (drumroll please) the only readily recognizable 303 pattern. Richie is, of course, a past master of Accent and Slide, and for several minutes you get some trademark low-key Plastic, with some 909 crash bringing things to a climax. Throughout there is good use of harmonic modulation. After 25:00 you get about 2 minutes of silence, a little varispeed 909+303 snippet, and then at 31:00 another 'hidden track' that sounds more Plastic-y than Namlook-y. There's even a short section with some 4 on the floor bass kick and handclaps on 2 and 4. Then Peter comes in with an analogue string pad to tie things together. It's as though he left the room for a smoke and when he came back, Richie was up to his old tricks again. So there you have it. I think it exhibits the strengths of both artists, and creates a definite warm mood, and it is not an aimless tweak-a-thon. Enjoy! -- kent.williams@cadsi.com [Kent Williams/CADSI/2651 Crosspark Rd/Coralville IA 52241/(319)626-6700] 3 Reasons Why Not to use OS/2: Half of the prisons in the United States are run by OS/2. The federal judicial system in many states is run on OS/2. Nearly every computer in police cars across America run OS/2.
1995-11-01 18:28Harvey ThornburgTemporary Insanity wrote: > 'Brain to Midi' is more in deep chill territory, starting out
From:
Harvey Thornburg
To:
Cc:
, , ,
Date:
Wed, 1 Nov 1995 10:28:33 -0800 (PST)
Subject:
Re: (idm) REVIEW: "From Within 2" Namlook/Hawtin
Reply to:
(idm) REVIEW: "From Within 2" Namlook/Hawtin
permalink · <199511011828.KAA17789@osiris.ac.hmc.edu>
Temporary Insanity wrote:
quoted 15 lines 'Brain to Midi' is more in deep chill territory, starting out> 'Brain to Midi' is more in deep chill territory, starting out > with quiet ring modulated speach sounds and distant rumbling. > Eventually a solo synth comes in and meanders about pleasantly, > to be joined by a one measure bassline pattern. It's a kind of > long jam on a spanish-sounding modal scale. Finally about 13 > minutes you finally get a little of Richie's Devilfish 303, and > then it's gone again almost as quickly. > > It's as well structured as 'Bass Drum' but it's not as > immediately inviting. And the name is something of a misnomer, > as the piece sounds like it was mostly done with analog-style > sequencers and live playing. There is such a thing as a > brainwave-to-midi convertor, but I seriously doubt they used it > here. >
If there is one track on the Fax label that sounds like mid-era Klaus Schulze, this is it! The melodies and extensive bits of non-sequenced live playing (these are the spanish-sounding modal scales) are dead giveaways. None of Schulze's three collaborations on Fax have approached this level of similarity to his older work (and there is no reason they should, regarding the "brain to midi" thing, it is tempting to think of this as a joke, that they applied their brains to the situation and just decided to improvise, forgetting anything about computer control :) However, if you listen really close to the filter on the lead synth (both tracks 1 and 2), you'll notice there is some quantization on the cutoff frequency. I assume this is Pete's synthi A which creates a conundrum as to how the quantization got there... It's blurred by more reverb in the second track, but still audible if you listen on really good headphones. So it's plausible they were using *some* measure of computer control, although the setup is probably more complex than it sounds. Also, the structure of the free-form synth lines is just a bit too fixed to attribute everything (minus the two sequenced motifs) to live improvisation. You'll notice that Schulze's improvisations try to stay in the same key for 10 minutes and then wander off into something else for 1 minute and then go back and then do something entirely different for the next 8 minutes... Anyway, the track is full of paradoxes as to exactly *how* they put it together, but it's unequivocally good (my favorite of the three).
quoted 13 lines 'Future Surfacing (What Lies Ahead)' is somewhat mistitled as> 'Future Surfacing (What Lies Ahead)' is somewhat mistitled as > well, it sounds a lot more like an early Tangerine Dream piece > than anything 'futuristic' Again we get a combination of > pattern sequencing with solos from Namlook. The pleasures here > come from slow introduction of one-bar melodic loops in > counterpoint over the course of the piece. Well into the piece > comes a nicely syncopated 909 pattern. And then (drumroll > please) the only readily recognizable 303 pattern. Richie is, > of course, a past master of Accent and Slide, and for several > minutes you get some trademark low-key Plastic, with some 909 > crash bringing things to a climax. Throughout there is good use > of harmonic modulation. >
perhaps the point of this track was to compare electronic styles old and new, or approximate what Tangerine Dream would have sounded like if 303's existed during the time when they were interested in this kind of analog sequencing. However, the periods of silence and entirely different last part (or "hidden track") indicate that the pairing is not as automatic as one would have hoped. Also, this is a bit too "layered" for my tastes as I actually go for Namlook's minimalism. Anyway, my opinion is that FW #2 is one of the best Fax releases in a while, but I prefer FW#1 slightly better. I think the first edition is more coherent and borrows from less people in terms of style, and there are standouts on FW#1 such as "Sad Alliance" which aren't even approached on the more recent disc. It's good, but I'm hungry for FW #3 :) ------------------------------------------------|---------------------------- "Categories strain, crack and break... | Harvey Thornburg Step out of the space provided." | ------------ -Steven Stapleton (1979) | hthornbu@osiris.ac.hmc.edu ------------------------------------------------|----------------------------