179,854Messages
9,130Senders
30Years
342mboxes

← back to listing · view thread

From:
Kevin Murphy
To:
Jonathan Hierholzer
Cc:
Date:
20 Feb 2002 00:02:36 -0800
Subject:
Re: [idm] Happy Geogaddi Day!
Msg-Id:
<1014192156.2575.31.camel@neko.eorbit.net>
In-Reply-To:
<OE62IfQdmEB4HGXAwxX00006c9e@hotmail.com>
Mbox:
idm.0202.gz
On Wed, 2002-02-20 at 00:41, Jonathan Hierholzer wrote:
quoted 5 lines I got my copy of Geogaddi in the mail today and wanted to know> I got my copy of Geogaddi in the mail today and wanted to know > everyone's opinions (initial, of course). Right off the bat, I was > personally underwhelmed, but the second time through hit me as > brilliant.. I can't make up my mind yet.. it's gonna take me quite a > while probably.
My experience was very similar. Much like the first time I listened to "Music Has A Right...", the first time through I kind of let it wash over me, and it didn't make a very strong impression. Then I put the headphones on and gave it a good listen. To paraphrase Beetlejuice, I've had it on repeat for about five hours now AND IT JUST KEEPS GETTIN' BETTER EVERY SINGLE TIME I HEAR IT! A few more first impressions: * A lot of the childish/nostalgic noises that gave "Music Has.." its sense of naivite seem to be twisted into something more anxious...more like the ghosts of children than the sounds of a schoolyard. * Is the manipulated vocal of the hypnotherapist on "The Devil Is In The Details" a tweak at every music reviewer who referred to BOC as "hypnotic", or is it just my overactive imagination? * "Julie and Candy" is *pretty*. :) * I'm really glad I didn't listen to bootlegs before I got the CD...It was kind of a letdown when I got the last Plaid album and realized that I'd already heard 90% of the tracks as mp3 boots. Hooray for delayed gratification. * "Dandelion" and "Energy Warning" bug me a bit insofar as the vocal samples are really obvious and the tracks themselves don't really go anywhere. But a minor nit overall. * Has anyone figured out what the heck the vocorded voice on "1969" is singing (not the "1969 in the sunshine" portion...)? -- Kevin Murphy "We buy junk and sell antiques." - sign on an antique store --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: idm-unsubscribe@hyperreal.org For additional commands, e-mail: idm-help@hyperreal.org