IDM Mailing Archive

1997-05-30 06:48Mad Frankie FraserI bet there's an industrial mailing list that you who want to discuss Trent Reznor and Cab

From:: Mad Frankie Fraser <frankie@gargamel.com>
To:: <idm@hyperreal.com>
Date:: Fri, 30 May 1997 08:48:49 +0200
Subject:: (idm) fuck reznor

I bet there's an industrial mailing list that you who want to discuss Trent Reznor and Cabaret Voltaire can join, cause it sure as hell doesn't belong here, and we even surer as heller don't want it here either. Fuck it. Fe. - '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' = ) - =-= = '''''''''' - - http://gargamel.com/plod -->-->--> -/ - - - ] '''''''' - - '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' = -.. =-= = '''''''''' -

1997-05-30 08:33ZanderOn Fri, 30 May 1997, Mad Frankie Fraser wrote: > I bet there's an industrial mailing list

From:: Zander <wls@U.Arizona.EDU>
To:: Mad Frankie Fraser <frankie@gargamel.com>
Cc:: <idm@hyperreal.com>
Date:: Fri, 30 May 1997 01:33:43 -0700 (MST)
Subject:: Re: (idm) fuck reznor
Reply to:: (idm) fuck reznor

On Fri, 30 May 1997, Mad Frankie Fraser wrote:

quoted 4 lines I bet there's an industrial mailing list that you who want to discuss Trent

> I bet there's an industrial mailing list that you who want to discuss Trent > Reznor and Cabaret Voltaire can join, cause it sure as hell doesn't belong > here, and we even surer as heller don't want it here either. > Fuck it.

I agree with this, I could care less what Trent Reznor does. His music does NOTHING (a pun) for me, and I could care less what he does. I don't really see the point in this thread, he get good people to remix him that's all I care to say about him. There is alt.music.nin for people who want to talk about him. I would much rather read about good musicians than read crap about him. William Samuels

1997-05-30 18:24Mark BowenOn May 30, 8:48am, Mad Frankie Fraser wrote: > Subject: (idm) fuck reznor > I bet there's

From:: Mark Bowen <mb@gettins.bche.uic.edu>
To:: Mad Frankie Fraser <frankie@gargamel.com>, <idm@hyperreal.com>
Date:: Fri, 30 May 1997 13:24:02 -0500
Subject:: Re: (idm) fuck reznor

On May 30, 8:48am, Mad Frankie Fraser wrote:

quoted 5 lines Subject: (idm) fuck reznor

> Subject: (idm) fuck reznor > I bet there's an industrial mailing list that you who want to discuss Trent > Reznor and Cabaret Voltaire can join, cause it sure as hell doesn't belong > here, and we even surer as heller don't want it here either. > Fuck it.

Reznor fine but Cab Voltaire??? How can you listen to the conversation lp on apollo and say it doesn't belong on IDM. Maybe CV was industrial in the 80s but the have been doing solid head techno for quite a while. -- Mark Edward Bowen Warmed Breakdown mb@gettins.bche.uic.edu

1997-05-30 20:37plod@gargamel.comAt 13:24 1997-05-30 -0500, you wrote: >On May 30, 8:48am, Mad Frankie Fraser wrote: >> Sub

From:: <plod@gargamel.com>
To:: <idm@hyperreal.com>
Date:: Fri, 30 May 1997 22:37:04 +0200
Subject:: Re: (idm) fuck reznor

At 13:24 1997-05-30 -0500, you wrote:

quoted 11 lines On May 30, 8:48am, Mad Frankie Fraser wrote:

>On May 30, 8:48am, Mad Frankie Fraser wrote: >> Subject: (idm) fuck reznor >> I bet there's an industrial mailing list that you who want to discuss Trent >> Reznor and Cabaret Voltaire can join, cause it sure as hell doesn't belong >> here, and we even surer as heller don't want it here either. >> Fuck it. > >Reznor fine but Cab Voltaire??? > >How can you listen to the conversation lp on apollo and say it doesn't belong >on IDM. Maybe CV was industrial in the 80s but the have been doing solid

head

quoted 2 lines techno for quite a while.

>techno for quite a while. >

Yeah, and I heard that Billy Ray Cyrus has stopped making ponypop... To whom it might concern: Please drop all these silly ass discussions of whats to be regarded as IDM and whats not to. (I got this feeling I ain´t the first one to say this...) Some ppl on this list probably likes CV, but I think the majority don´t care that much ´bout them. (I could be wrong!) Therefore, I bet you´ll get more understanding and positive answers on topics such as CV, NIN, FLA or whatever on the Industrial list. //DiscoDuck#2 (who happens to have a copy of "Drinking Gasoline" which I just can´t wait to get rid off!) :) http://gargamel.com/plod Peter Wahlbeck for President!

1997-05-30 21:25chris r graves>>Reznor fine but Cab Voltaire??? >> >>How can you listen to the conversation lp on apollo

From:: chris r graves <grav@juno.com>
To:: <idm@hyperreal.com>
Date:: Fri, 30 May 1997 17:25:32 EDT
Subject:: Re: (idm) fuck reznor

quoted 4 lines Reznor fine but Cab Voltaire???

>>Reznor fine but Cab Voltaire??? >> >>How can you listen to the conversation lp on apollo and say it doesn't >>belong on IDM. Maybe CV was industrial in the 80s but the have been

doing

quoted 12 lines solid head techno for quite a while.

>>solid head techno for quite a while. > >Yeah, and I heard that Billy Ray Cyrus has stopped making ponypop... >To whom it might concern: >Please drop all these silly ass discussions of whats to be >regarded as IDM and whats not to. (I got this feeling I ain?t the >first one to say this...) >Some ppl on this list probably likes CV, but I think the >majority don?t care that much ?bout them. (I could be wrong!) >Therefore, I bet you?ll get more understanding and >positive answers on topics such as CV, NIN, FLA or >whatever on the Industrial list.

Hopefully this will be the last message I see of this. Personally, I have never heard Richard H. Kirk make anything that sounded like industrial. From Cab Volt, Sandoz, Electronic Eye, and his own name is where I can make this statement. His more recent things have been complete groove if you ask me and are definitely danceable and intelligent. I do not know about his earlier stuff and it may have been 'industrial', but not now. I don't see how someone can compare Kirk to Reznor. They sound completely different. End of discussion.. if a reply make it private so you don't clutter up the mailing list.. grav