179,854Messages
9,130Senders
30Years
342mboxes

← back to listing · view thread

From:
Che
To:
Intelligent Dumb Music
Date:
Sat, 7 Jun 1997 13:37:58 +0000 ()
Subject:
Re: (idm) anti-idm
Msg-Id:
<Pine.BSD.3.91.970607133451.10997B-100000@beacon.synthcom.com>
Mbox:
idm.9706.gz
At 08:32 PM 6/6/97 -0400, KaisrSolze@aol.com wrote:
quoted 8 lines For a decidedly different perspective on many of idm's favorites, go to>For a decidedly different perspective on many of idm's favorites, go to >http://members.aol.com/blissout/sr2.htm >Simon Reynolds writes for various decent papers, etc, and has been behind >techstep for quite a while. He's a relatively intelligent, or at least >thoughtful guy. Check his view on Squarepusher. I don't agree with Mr. >Reynolds, but we seem to get stuck in a rut on this list from time to >time(except for the Black Dog Droid, who likes to piss on the party on >occasion).
Read closely and you'll find Mr. Reynolds is constantly contradicting himself - perhaps a symptom of wanting to be simultaneously trendy and bleeding edge. For instance, he pisses on Squarepusher for daring to threaten the orthodoxy of drum & bass by bringing in techno elements, while also claiming that he's been wishing for years that ambient/intelligent jungle & intelligent techno could cross-pollinate (see the Breakbeat Science blurb). He rails on about jungle's gentrification/muzak-isation, but woe be to him that rebels against the sameness created by the ultra-insular "scene" which he finds being a member of so necessary to establish the credentials of anyone making jungle. (and why DOES he insist on calling it jungle, anyway?) He slams Jockey Slut for "Detroit-pietism", while dropping the name of Suburban Knight on his year's best, not because Suburban Knight really did anything last year (or for that matter, in the last 5 years), but because he felt the need to display his own piety. Enjoy the wordplay, but don' take it seriously. Che