179,854Messages
9,130Senders
30Years
342mboxes

← archive index

Re: (313) new Shake on Frictional, the nature of criticism

1 message · 1 participant · spans 1 day · search this subject
1995-06-14 22:58Dave Walker Re: (313) new Shake on Frictional, the nature of criticism
expand allcollapse allclick any summary to toggle that message
1995-06-14 22:58Dave WalkerOn Wed, 14 Jun 1995, Matt MacQueen wrote: > I mean, nobody said shit after I criticized th
From:
Dave Walker
To:
Detroit Techno Mailing List
Cc:
I D M
Date:
Wed, 14 Jun 1995 18:58:49 -0400 (EDT)
Subject:
Re: (313) new Shake on Frictional, the nature of criticism
permalink · <Pine.BSD/.3.91.950614183120.17889B-100000@conch.aa.msen.com>
On Wed, 14 Jun 1995, Matt MacQueen wrote:
quoted 4 lines I mean, nobody said shit after I criticized the Dopplereffekt L.P, for *or*> I mean, nobody said shit after I criticized the Dopplereffekt L.P, for *or* > against it. I think to be a honest reviewer (whatever that is) than you > should posts the "ok's" and "fairs" as much as you should post the > "amazing!'s".
I hope this doesn't come out weird, but here goes... I have a real hard time writing about "middling" music -- stuff that doesn't hit me strongly (positively or negatively) either way. I probably review less than 25% of the stuff I pick up. I can bring CD's to work and give them "deeper" attention, but with 12" singles I generally have to tape and listen to in the car. Anything that doesn't strike me as particularly memorable doesn't even get taped -- with the phucked hours I'm working these days time is the most precious commodity. I have a rough time writing about those "middling" records because in all honesty I can't be fair to them -- if I haven't spent enough time with them to say anything deeper than "loved it" or "hated it" or "nodded out snoring over the slipmats" then I feel like I'm not being fair to the producer or the other people on the mailing list reading the review. _ stay tuned for freeke reviews #9 and #10 (electro special) I mean it this time! :) on now: Deep Space, which keeps sounding better and better on last in the car: some forgettable (but not _horrible_) trax-y thing which I probably won't bother writing about :) ----------------------------------------------------------------- dave walker, detroit art services marmoset@conch.aa.msen.com sivie minieskrot <A HREF="http://www.msen.com/~marmoset/">Dave Walker</A>