179,854Messages
9,130Senders
30Years
342mboxes

← archive index

Re: (idm) [review] Mask 2 (complete with the guessing game)

6 messages · 4 participants · spans 1 day · search this subject
◇ merged from 2 subjects: (idm) [review] mask 2 (complete with the guessing game) · (idm) mp3s, realaudio, audio compression
1997-08-11 03:11(idm) [review] Mask 2 (complete with the guessing game)
1997-08-11 18:45daniel re: (idm) [review] Mask 2 (complete with the guessing game)
1997-08-11 21:17Re: (idm) [review] Mask 2 (complete with the guessing game)
├─ 1997-08-11 21:42daniel Re: (idm) [review] Mask 2 (complete with the guessing game)
│ └─ 1997-08-11 15:14Emanuel Borsboom Re: (idm) mp3s, realaudio, audio compression
└─ 1997-08-12 01:15Re: (idm) [review] Mask 2 (complete with the guessing game)
expand allcollapse allclick any summary to toggle that message
1997-08-11 03:11MultSanta@aol.comMask 2 quasi-review: just downloaded the entire mask 2 mp3s (all 25 mbs of it, would have
From:
To:
Date:
Sun, 10 Aug 1997 23:11:58 -0400 (EDT)
Subject:
(idm) [review] Mask 2 (complete with the guessing game)
permalink · <970810231157_345841529@emout06.mail.aol.com>
Mask 2 quasi-review: just downloaded the entire mask 2 mp3s (all 25 mbs of it, would have been no more than 3 in real audio). Anyway, I must applaud both skam and Musik Aus Stromm. This baby burns. Much better than I expected, even with all the hype. Definetly some of the better stuff I've listened to so far this year. So the label says "appearing in no particular order - hellinterface funkstorung intron bola jega" and hellinterface=boards of canada. Let the guessing game begin: 1: pure beauty mixed with a fast breakbeaty rythym. Although this does not sound like much of the other stuff I'm gonna say that this is hellinterface, cuz a new name means a new angle on the music (unless your name happens to be richard d. james, in which a new name means another in a list of dozens) And the general feel of BoC is still there (I can't put my finger on it, it's something though) 2: Ahh reminicent of the old Ae tri repate era, but with more of a musical twist. There's only one person who could be responsible for this track. Yep you guessed it, Jega. 3: noisey-ass track sounds like putting your ear up next to the train track with a locomotive on it's way (advice to small children, and bigger ones,too: DONT TRY THIS AT HOME, I am a "train"ed proffesional <-- big time chessey joke in effect) Anyway "storung" is german for distortion. We know this baby gots lots of that. It is, however, lacking funk, but one out of two ain't bad: funkstorung 4: Now, I'm confused, cause this track sounds like it could be jega, also, or BoC. But, to reduce the risk of my entire review falling apart, I'm gonna have to go with Bola. 5. Creepy piano opening followed by dark strings and "ahhs". Excelent way to end the disc. Process of elimination folks: Intron Now I'm intriuged by this whole mask mystery. Anyone want to sell mask1 (or 2, for that matter)? I'll pay top $$. How about someone encodes mask1 in mp3 also? I've got to be sure to hunt down 3 if/when it comes out. Let's hear all your guesses. PS: Thanks to all who've been recording all the mp3/ra around here. I'm glad to see this list finally taking advantage of the audio offerings of the net. Looks like Gonzi, Grant, Sm@4thWorld, and myself struck a chord with our offerings (all with the help of sfwd@sonic.net, of course- thanks). I'm looking forward to hearing more from you all. pps: anyone hear the plaid show?, I just found that thing: http://www.abc.se/~m9550/plaid_live.html how long has it been up? Looking forward to listening to that, too. keep the encoding going, mult. http://members.aol.com/MultSanta2
1997-08-11 18:45danielMultSanta@aol.com wrote: >just downloaded the entire mask 2 mp3s (all 25 mbs of it, would
From:
daniel
To:
Date:
Mon, 11 Aug 1997 13:45:14 -0500 (CDT)
Subject:
re: (idm) [review] Mask 2 (complete with the guessing game)
permalink · <Pine.BSF.3.96.970811133840.25128A-100000@lestat.daniel.blkbox.com>
MultSanta@aol.com wrote:
quoted 2 lines just downloaded the entire mask 2 mp3s (all 25 mbs of it, would have been>just downloaded the entire mask 2 mp3s (all 25 mbs of it, would have been >no more than 3 in real audio).
If it had been done in RA at just 3 megs it would not have been close to cd quality. 3 megs is great if I want to get an idea what the song is about. But, if I wanted to hear depth and appreciate it on a deeper level I would definitely need something a hell of alot better and bigger. Note, RA could be used for this and it would be huge as well. That is encode it in dual isdn. Don't know about everyone else but I have my computer hooked to my stereo and I can tell the difference between a low quality encoding and high quality encoding. Not that I care either way. I am glad to have it in any medium presented. Just wanted to point out some facts. just my 2 cents worth... n.p. Two Lone Swordsman - the fifth mission
1997-08-11 21:17MultSanta@aol.comIn a message dated 97-08-11 15:47:38 EDT, daniel@eliteware.com (daniel) writes: << If it h
From:
To:
,
Date:
Mon, 11 Aug 1997 17:17:31 -0400 (EDT)
Subject:
Re: (idm) [review] Mask 2 (complete with the guessing game)
permalink · <970811171654_1611635720@emout04.mail.aol.com>
In a message dated 97-08-11 15:47:38 EDT, daniel@eliteware.com (daniel) writes: << If it had been done in RA at just 3 megs it would not have been close to cd quality. >> yes, but a record isn't supposed to be cd quality, now is it? mult. http://members.aol.com/MultSanta2
1997-08-11 21:42danielOn Mon, 11 Aug 1997 MultSanta@aol.com wrote: > In a message dated 97-08-11 15:47:38 EDT, d
From:
daniel
To:
Cc:
Date:
Mon, 11 Aug 1997 16:42:18 -0500 (CDT)
Subject:
Re: (idm) [review] Mask 2 (complete with the guessing game)
Reply to:
Re: (idm) [review] Mask 2 (complete with the guessing game)
permalink · <Pine.BSF.3.96.970811163013.25280A-100000@lestat.daniel.blkbox.com>
On Mon, 11 Aug 1997 MultSanta@aol.com wrote:
quoted 8 lines In a message dated 97-08-11 15:47:38 EDT, daniel@eliteware.com (daniel)> In a message dated 97-08-11 15:47:38 EDT, daniel@eliteware.com (daniel) > writes: > > << If it had been done in RA at just 3 megs it would not have been close to > cd quality. >> > > yes, but a record isn't supposed to be cd quality, now is it? >
uhmmmm well a record isn't supposed to be radio/telephone quality is it now? When you record a 12 inch and mp3 it you are sampling it. The more samples the more it will sound like the original record. The more samples the larger the file. So if you sample something and encode at a very high quality it will be close to how the original sounded. By your method I would be receiving a file that sounded like the record being played through a bad radio station or even worse through a phone. The sound quality of an mp3 is close to that of a cd <which have a high sampling rate (44.1k per second to be exact)>. So the mp3 is close to how the record really sounded. Note I am not saying that mp3 uses sample rates in the traditional sense. A dual isdn ra file can come close to cd quality as well. You may want to pick up a book on how recordings are done. -dan
1997-08-11 15:14Emanuel BorsboomOn Mon, 11 Aug 1997, daniel wrote: > The sound quality of an mp3 is close to that of a cd
From:
Emanuel Borsboom
To:
Date:
Mon, 11 Aug 1997 15:14:00 -0700 (Pacific Daylight Time)
Subject:
Re: (idm) mp3s, realaudio, audio compression
Reply to:
Re: (idm) [review] Mask 2 (complete with the guessing game)
permalink · <Pine.WNT.3.96.970811145110.215D-100000@hayfever.zerius.victoria.bc.ca>
On Mon, 11 Aug 1997, daniel wrote:
quoted 4 lines The sound quality of an mp3 is close to that of a cd <which have a high> The sound quality of an mp3 is close to that of a cd <which have a high > sampling rate (44.1k per second to be exact)>. So the mp3 is close > to how the record really sounded. Note I am not saying that mp3 uses > sample rates in the traditional sense.
Actually, MP3 does use sample rates in the traditional sense. Most MP3s use the same sample rate (44100 khz) and bittage (16 bits/sample) as a CD. The lame old way of of data reduction was reducing the sample-rate and/or bittage (so basically it's just throwing out all frequencies above a certain threshhold). The way MP3, ATRAC, and (I think) RealAudio works is by selectively removing frequencies we can't hear anyway (because of psychoacoustical effects such as masking, where a frequency that's a lot quieter than a nearby frequency is ignored by the brain). Most MP3s are encoded at 112 kbps (because that's the best the unregistered shareware encoder will do), while 44.1 khz/16 bit/2 channel uncompressed data from a CD is 1411.2 kbps, which is (approx.) 12:1 compression, so for every frequency in the original, 11 have been removed for the MP3. For some reason, 128 kbps MP3s sound quite noticably better even though their compression ratio isn't much lower. An MP3 with the same bit rate as a RealAudio file will sound better than the RealAudio, because MP3 uses a better (much slower) algorithm for compression. ATRAC is supposed to be even better than MP3, but it's proprietry and there aren't any software encoders/decoders (it's what MiniDisc recorders use.. I just had to mention MiniDisc somewhere :-)) For speech you can use vocoding for amazing compression ratios with very little loss in clarity. That's actually the original reason vocoders were invented. Their use as a musical instrument is just a side effect. onNow: Exist Dance - Transmitting From Heaven (there was a documentary on the (Canadian) Discovery Channel last night called Synthetic Pleasures that used lots of the tracks from this comp.) By the way, I'm starting to like the new Jega a lot better now. -- Emanuel Borsboom -- Victoria, B.C., Canada -- "complete with surface noise" [Home Page] http://zerius.com/manny/ [Java Synth] http://zerius.com/synth/ [Vocoder] http://zerius.com/vocoder/
1997-08-12 01:15sanvara@gte.netAt 05:17 PM 8/11/97 -0400, you wrote: > ><< If it had been done in RA at just 3 megs it wo
From:
To:
Date:
Mon, 11 Aug 1997 18:15:19 -0700
Subject:
Re: (idm) [review] Mask 2 (complete with the guessing game)
Reply to:
Re: (idm) [review] Mask 2 (complete with the guessing game)
permalink · <3.0.1.32.19970811181519.006f1ee8@mail.gte.net>
At 05:17 PM 8/11/97 -0400, you wrote:
quoted 4 lines << If it had been done in RA at just 3 megs it would not have been close to> ><< If it had been done in RA at just 3 megs it would not have been close to > cd quality. >> > >yes, but a record isn't supposed to be cd quality, now is it?
Heh. Maybe not, but a low quality RA file is like "eaten by the tape player five times, cassette quality". =) T.