179,854Messages
9,130Senders
30Years
342mboxes

← back to listing · view thread

From:
James Roberts
To:
Idm List ,
Date:
Sun, 2 Jan 2000 11:34:10 -0000
Subject:
Re: (idm) 99 chart (about 50% OTP)
Msg-Id:
<001101bf5515$6a88fd20$7e42883e@wzngemxm>
Mbox:
idm.0001.gz
quoted 1 line ***true. this morning i read a review of it where it was described as>***true. this morning i read a review of it where it was described as
"prince
quoted 1 line meets autechre". i understand referencing prince re: this, but *autechre*?>meets autechre". i understand referencing prince re: this, but *autechre*?
I just
quoted 5 lines think this was another case of lazy "journalism" where IDM = autechre and>think this was another case of lazy "journalism" where IDM = autechre and >anything electronic = autechre and autechre becomes the "brand name" of >IDM these days (for those who *don't* understand, want to, or even try to) >in the same way that a certain RDJ used to be. Makes me >understand all the more while acts like Solvent hate getting likened to
Autechre,
quoted 1 line and so many others too (that is, get likened to Autechre). Heck, not>and so many others too (that is, get likened to Autechre). Heck, not
dissin'
quoted 1 line autechre here, just those who think namedropping Autechre in a review>autechre here, just those who think namedropping Autechre in a review
brings
quoted 1 line up their "writer's status". Andrew Duke>up their "writer's status". Andrew Duke
Too right. Autechre are fantastic, but their popularity does them no credit (if you see what I mean); it seems like the IDM world ends with them for a lot of people (myself included - I've only just started to look outside of Warp for music). The journalists who do these stories probably haven't been fully immersed in the IM culture - their waypoints are in more mainstream electronic (moby, fatboy slim, etc. etc.), so obviously these bands will sound like Ae to them. Conditioning, that's the word. ...On the other hand, I suspect that many of their readers will be in the same situation. If that kind of reporting, however misleading, gets Ae fans listening to a wider range of music, can that really be a bad thing? James Roberts ------ http://listen.to/isds www.mp3.com/isds --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: idm-unsubscribe@hyperreal.org For additional commands, e-mail: idm-help@hyperreal.org