quoted 3 lines No I can't. As long as there's the possibility that the texture was> No I can't. As long as there's the possibility that the texture was
> designed exactly how it was laid down, there's no assumption to be made
> about why it sounds the way it does.
either way, it sounds amateur. I could have the music I write sound
similar (in mixing quality) by putting less effort into cleaning it up.
It would then be intentional. Artistic? if it is, there's no
creativity or message really involved with the process other than "I
suck at mixing, and/or I'm too lazy to clean this up".
That's not art, that's sloppiness. Clicks and cuts is a much better
display of using peaking and popping in a creative format.
quoted 6 lines You're confusing your music-making predilections with your listening>
> You're confusing your music-making predilections with your listening
> experience, which tends to influence musicians' descriptions of music that
> they themselves didn't make. Questions of intent are a mind-game to no
> end, and why should anyone care whether you would make the same choices if
> you were the composer? You yourself say its a matter of intolerance.
odds are, it wasn't intentional. odds are, you're taking the
pretentious "artist fucking with listener" backdoor in this discussion.
-mark
ps: that was not meant as a flame, but an observation.
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: idm-unsubscribe@hyperreal.org
For additional commands, e-mail: idm-help@hyperreal.org