179,854Messages
9,130Senders
30Years
342mboxes

← back to listing · view thread

From:
Paul McFadyen
To:
grey , IDM List
Date:
Tue, 25 Nov 1997 17:11:00 -0000
Subject:
RE: (idm) IDM/AFX/Prodigy Thoughts
Msg-Id:
<9711251711.AA11684@gatekeeper.cableol.net>
Mbox:
idm.9711.gz
quoted 3 lines Is Plastikman IDM? Sure. Lots of people have said so. Plastikman while>Is Plastikman IDM? Sure. Lots of people have said so. Plastikman while >minimalist maintains an enormous amount of subtlety and undeniable >intelligence.
quoted 1 line What about Hardfloor? Before you spring to your toes and try to lynch>What about Hardfloor? Before you spring to your toes and try to lynch
me,
quoted 2 lines consider their careful buildups, their exquisite use of the 303, their>consider their careful buildups, their exquisite use of the 303, their >crashing climaxes, the twists and turns they take, and tell me that
isn't
quoted 1 line subtle. Tell me that isn't intelligent.>subtle. Tell me that isn't intelligent.
Right firstly you say that IDM isn't dance music, then you say that Plastikman and Hardfloor are IDM. Have you ever seen the effect that a Hardfloor track has on a dancefloor? I would say that a high percentage of IDM doesn't exactly set a dancefloor alight, but certain artists can be intelligent with their music without losing the dance edge (Hardfloor for one) I totally agree with you about the Prodigy though. I'll get a thousand abusive e-mails for this, but I would describe the Prodigy as IDM. Given that a lot of their stuff is crap, but listen to "Narayan" and take away the vocals and you're left with a very intelligent atmospheric piece of music - listen to Claustrophobic Sting. It's a shame that the MTV generation have picked up on Liam's work, but at least he still keeps the edge despite commercial pressures. See Ya Paul