IDM Mailing Archive

On 3 May 99, Darren Keast wrote re: (idm) Intelligent trance???:

quoted 2 lines The only trance I hear is really

> The only trance I hear is really > obnoxious and pop-ish...is that all there is?

I'm quite looking forward to getting the new Total Eclipse release on blueroom... they're more known for their straight-up goa but their last 2cd set had a full cd of great chillout stuff, it's still one of my favorite albums (the other cd fills the extra space in the box nicely). Look for the Infinite Excursions comps on TIP too for more interesting chilled psy trance... Cheers Joh

On 28 Apr 99, John wrote re: Re: (idm) Intelligent trance???:

quoted 1 line look for the Infinite Excursions comps on TIP

> look for the Infinite Excursions comps on TIP

Speaking of which : does anybody know the release date of TIPCD07? It's one of the earlier TIP Infinite Excursions with some pretty nice stuff on it (opens with Shpongle). Undated though. I *

one other reason dj's aren't meshing more styles together seems to stem from all these bullshit events that book hundreds of dj's. even if it's multiple rooms, the longest set a dj will get is two hours. how much ground can you cover in that alloted time without sounding completely schitzo? i miss the old days. parties had a warm up dj, a live event, a closer dj. give the two dj's four hour sets and the live act two. you can't please all the people all the time, so why try? ($cough$) on now: lb 'jealous guy' (kk) here's the new atom heart shit... and it's all cover versions! cameron ===================================== cameron bowden cameron@imagina.com blacksmith on the anvil in your ear _____________________________________

quoted 3 lines i miss the old days. parties had a warm up dj, a live event, a closer dj.

> i miss the old days. parties had a warm up dj, a live event, a closer dj. > give the two dj's four hour sets and the live act two. you can't please all > the people all the time, so why try? ($cough$)

very agreed... the problem is though... how many djs can "handle" djing for more than 90-120 minutes...shit nowadays 60 minutes is the normal set... ?? of the djing ive seen over the past years... the ones that stand out are the long building sets: i.e. Mixmaster Morris, Lauren Garnier, Richie Hawtin... david morales, danny teneglia, carl cox....and well thats about all.. a few other sets stand out...(atmospheric audio chair--chicago..but thats more of a collective) but are not even in the same "league" as what tese individuals have done. i agree let djs who can pspin for over 3 hours... LET THEM. but as was mentioned in a deleted section: the promoters need $$$$ very few djs can have the draw of the aforementioned djs. therefore we will still continue tos ee less of it....unless in a club.setting (which is fine by me...the club setting that is..just wish more clubs were near me) anyways..let the chaos continue

One of the things I like about this list the most is when someone will say <drum and bass, techno, house, hip-hop, fill in the blank> is dead, and then a bunch of other people respond with great examples of innovative artists in the given genre. The one category I've never heard defended on this list is trance...is there any trance that people out there like? The only trance I hear is really obnoxious and pop-ish...is that all there is? wondering, darren

On 3 May 99, Darren Keast wrote re: (idm) Intelligent trance???:

quoted 2 lines The only trance I hear is really

> The only trance I hear is really > obnoxious and pop-ish...is that all there is?

I'm NOT *defending* trance. Just a few comments. There's a healthy and alive trance 'scene' here in South Africa (as is in Israel, I believe) and this is probably partially due to the fine weather allowing open-air gatherings and all-weekend raves somewhere in some scenic place out in the bush far enough for the noise not to bother locals and out of the way of snooping cops. I have a very close friend and part-time DJ whose musical taste overlaps largely with mine, except that he is also into trance and has dragged me along to a few events. Of these, I have been most impressed by the recent Suzuki gig - but then, he wasn't playing straight-up trance (in fact, the majority of trance-heads there were very disappointed) but some of the Matsuri stuff is well worth investigating if you want to broaden your musical cathment area. Simon Posford (Hallucinogen/Shpongle) puts together some interesting sets live and what I've heard on disc (check his "Twisted" label) is also impressive from the amount of work that he obviously puts into it. Where techno (for example) is made up of repeated loops, so is trance, but every time the loop comes round, something subtley changes - there are an enormous amount of layers and textures and millions of little things going on. I can hear and appreciate this, but it generally leaves me cold without connecting. You mention "obnoxious and pop-ish" - (no, that's not all there is). There are several sub-genres of trance, just as there are in other formats. There's goa - with insanely high BPM's, there's also progressive trance, uplifting trance - you-name-it trance. My favourite would have to be ambient dub trance, most of which could happily sit in anybody's IDM collection. In fact, as we speak I'm listening to an album on the German mainly trance label Spirit Zone by an outfit called Patchwork (Album "Odeon: 1998) which I'd classify as IDM rather than trance. This was lent to me by the friend I mentioned above and I've been enjoying it a lot. It's unobnoxious, very pleasant and well crafted. Would fit well into any set that goes the Kruder & Dorfmeister route. Go investigate it. I *

On 4 May 99, I wrote re: Re: (idm) Intelligent trance???:

quoted 2 lines Spirit Zone by an outfit called Patchwork

> Spirit Zone by an outfit called Patchwork > (Album "Odeon: 1998)

Oops ... upon closer inspection it would appear that the group is ODEON and the album title is Patchwork ... sorry if anybody got as confused as me :-) I *

I'm by no means an expert on trance and my collection of trance records numbers less than I have fingers, but this question has been posed before and the universal answered tended to be LSG (Oliver Lieb). I have yet to find a trace record that could match the power and brilliance of his "Collected Works" disc on hooj choons. perfectly mixed, intelligent effects, picks you up and doesn't stop until 69:33 minutes later. when I first got it, 'Collected Works' stayed in my discman for a solid month and served as the perfect accompaniment to my daily commute from suburbaban Chicago into the Loop. excellent energy. as far as trance labels are concerned, feedback I've received points towards the aforementioned Hooj Choons and Platipus as well. hooj choons online: http://www.fortunecity.com/tinpan/morrissey/587/index.html daevid j

quoted 10 lines From: Darren Keast <darren@skinny.com>

>From: Darren Keast <darren@skinny.com> >Subject: (idm) Intelligent trance??? > >The one category I've never heard defended on this list is trance...is >there any trance that people out there like? The only trance I hear is really >obnoxious and pop-ish...is that all there is? > >wondering, > >darren

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ "I want more life, f*cker." - Roy Batty, circa 2019 Join 18 million Eudora users by signing up for a free Eudora Web-Mail account at http://www.eudoramail.com

I just heard this thing by Ekko on Interchill, called 'Centripetal.' You could call it trance, I suppose... highly improvised, with tabla and this funny droning bass-guitar-tamboura-harp thing called the stikharp. Maybe not all that intellectually stimulating, but significantly more interesting than a lot of trance because it has some improvisation on it. You could call it 'jam trance' or 'ethno trance' or something like that, I suppose.

I've mentioned this before, but it bears repeating: Posford's side project Shpongle put out a great disc called "Are You Shpongled?" at the end of last year. Very intricately programmed, a lot of attention paid to crafting the sounds used -- and a live flute player. Fun stuff; the last two tracks are mindblowing. Lukas

quoted 10 lines Date: Tue, 4 May 1999 10:03:55 +0200

> Date: Tue, 4 May 1999 10:03:55 +0200 > From: "Irene McC" <substar@iafrica.com> > Subject: Re: (idm) Intelligent trance??? > Simon Posford (Hallucinogen/Shpongle) puts together some > interesting sets live and what I've heard on disc (check his > "Twisted" label) is also impressive from the amount of work that he > obviously puts into it. Where techno (for example) is made up of > repeated loops, so is trance, but every time the loop comes round, > something subtley changes - there are an enormous amount of > layers and textures and millions of little things going on.

In a message dated 5/4/99 8:09:53 PM Mountain Daylight Time, JACOBSON@frodo.mgh.harvard.edu writes:

quoted 2 lines Maybe

> Maybe > not all that intellectually stimulating,

Trance is not intellectually stimulating because it's repetative, and mathmatics is not intellectually stimulating because it's repetative.

quoted 8 lines In a message dated 5/4/99 8:09:53 PM Mountain Daylight Time,

> In a message dated 5/4/99 8:09:53 PM Mountain Daylight Time, > JACOBSON@frodo.mgh.harvard.edu writes: > >> Maybe >> not all that intellectually stimulating, > > Trance is not intellectually stimulating because it's repetative, and > mathmatics is not intellectually stimulating because it's repetative.

What about minimal? pretty repetetive, yet i doubt you would be addressing brinkman with that opinion. Trance sucks for other reasons - similar ones to why house sucks. cb

quoted 1 line One of the things I like about this list the most is when someone will say

> One of the things I like about this list the most is when someone will say

<drum

quoted 1 line and bass, techno, house, hip-hop, fill in the blank> is dead, and then a

> and bass, techno, house, hip-hop, fill in the blank> is dead, and then a

bunch of

quoted 1 line other people respond with great examples of innovative artists in the

> other people respond with great examples of innovative artists in the

given

quoted 1 line genre. The one category I've never heard defended on this list is

> genre. The one category I've never heard defended on this list is

trance...is

quoted 1 line there any trance that people out there like? The only trance I hear is

> there any trance that people out there like? The only trance I hear is

really

quoted 1 line obnoxious and pop-ish...is that all there is?

> obnoxious and pop-ish...is that all there is?

What about Speedy J? He is undoubtedly an IDM artist, but some of his stuff is really trancey (like his 'live' album or some tracks from "G-Spot"). I think System 7's "Fire" album can also be called intelligent trance. And of course Orbital and their "Orbital 2" album. Nick.

On 7 May 99, Nick Zavriev wrote re: Re: (idm) Intelligent trance???:

quoted 2 lines What about Speedy J? He is undoubtedly an IDM artist, but some of his

> What about Speedy J? He is undoubtedly an IDM artist, but some of his > stuff is really trancey (like his 'live' album

GOOD POINT. I've also always thought that. Still, "Pepper" is one of my very favourites. I *

In a message dated 5/5/99 9:01:30 AM Mountain Daylight Time, omshanti@123.net writes:

quoted 3 lines What about minimal? pretty repetetive, yet i doubt you would be addressing

> What about minimal? pretty repetetive, yet i doubt you would be addressing > brinkman with that opinion. Trance sucks for other reasons - similar ones > to why house sucks.

I was more or less talking about the idea of trance, trance inducing music, and how to create good trance.. I agree, typical trance, speaking towards the genre, is crap for the most part.. it's actually wannabe stuff from a higher form of music. The trance that is commonly heard is clubs is a cheap untalented wannabe of what it should be.

quoted 6 lines I was more or less talking about the idea of trance, trance inducing music,

>I was more or less talking about the idea of trance, trance inducing music, >and how to create good trance.. I agree, typical trance, speaking towards >the >genre, is crap for the most part.. it's actually wannabe stuff from a higher >form of music. The trance that is commonly heard is clubs is a cheap >untalented wannabe of what it should be.

IM SO SICK AND TIRED OF WANNABE TRANCE FANS CALLING THE GENRE MOSTLY CRAP FOR THE MOST PART.. YOU OBVIOUSLY ARE TOO NARROW MINDED TO APPRECIATE TRANCE FOR THE BEAUTIFUL ART IT IS!!! ok, ok.. ok.. nuff tee-hee Ernesto Ikerd, (817) 763-4795 Company Graphics, Dept 17, MZ-1156 Lockheed Martin Tactical Aircraft Systems Fort Worth, Texas

In a message dated 5/11/99 11:09:51 AM Mountain Daylight Time, IkerdEA@lmtas.lmco.com writes:

quoted 6 lines IM SO SICK AND TIRED OF WANNABE TRANCE FANS CALLING THE GENRE MOSTLY CRAP

> > IM SO SICK AND TIRED OF WANNABE TRANCE FANS CALLING THE GENRE MOSTLY CRAP > FOR THE MOST PART.. YOU OBVIOUSLY ARE TOO NARROW MINDED TO APPRECIATE > TRANCE FOR THE BEAUTIFUL ART IT IS!!! > > ok, ok.. ok.. nuff tee-hee

YEAH THAT'S THE SPIRIT!!! I still think trance is crap but YEAH!!! hehe -=Aaron