179,854Messages
9,130Senders
30Years
342mboxes

← archive index

(idm) re: porter ricks

1 message · 1 participant · spans 1 day · search this subject
1999-03-22 04:02Joshua Reuven (idm) re: porter ricks
expand allcollapse allclick any summary to toggle that message
1999-03-22 04:02Joshua Reuven> > As an anti-four-on-the-floor type (by which I don't mean "ABOLISH 4OTF!" > > or someth
From:
Joshua Reuven
To:
,
Date:
Mon, 22 Mar 1999 00:02:21 -0400
Subject:
(idm) re: porter ricks
permalink · <36F5C0CC.22E0@erols.com>
quoted 23 lines As an anti-four-on-the-floor type (by which I don't mean "ABOLISH 4OTF!"> > As an anti-four-on-the-floor type (by which I don't mean "ABOLISH 4OTF!" > > or something, just that I don't like it) I can personally attest to not > > liking Chain Reaction. Porter Ricks is something I feel like I really > > OUGHT to like, and I don't find myself turning it off quite as swiftly > > as the other stuff I've heard on the label, but all in all I hear about > > a minute of it and think "Why am I listening to this?" > > > > I've tried very hard to like Chain Reaction - reviews on idm, in the > > Wire, and all over the place exhort me to go and buy. However, it does > > nothing for me. Nice ambient sounds, I like the glitches and > > weirdnesses, but fuck me, those beats drive me mad. It's probably just a > > general house thing - I like very little house, and this is reflected in > > my opinion of minimal house stuff. [Don't think I'm dismissing > > everything with a kick drum on every beat (given that most d'n'b, and > > most hip-hop too, is in 4/4...) or whatever. I love Underworld's first > > two dance albums (ie dubnobasswithmyheadman and second toughest...) even > > now, but listening to the latest album I can't help feeling disappointed > > - - some of it's lovely, but a lot is just boring] > > > > Ah! Boring. That's the word I was looking for. Chain Reaction bores me > > to tears. Y'know, there's minimal and there's minimal. Steve Reich will > > never bore me; same with Underworld's loooong epics, because they have > > an overarching structure that builds, goes somewhere, does something.
that's *exactly* how i feel, and i probably should have gone to some legnths to say that originally.
quoted 6 lines Final note: I'm not sure about the causality here, but Mego put out> > Final note: I'm not sure about the causality here, but Mego put out > > glorious glitchy and weird stuff which I think is on entirely another > > level from Chain Reaction. I doubt that one of them came first, but in > > terms of "ground-breaking", I think Mego [Fennesz, Farmers Manual, > > General Magic, Pita etc] are about as ground-breaking as it gets these > > days. I would also include Matmos in that league...
another thing i totally agree with you. mego is my favorite label and i feel to be releasing the far most ground breaking stuff in several years. i didn't want to bring them up though as an example...i don't want to turn this into a mego vs. chain reaction, as the labels are VERY different... but in my opinion, mego is the best out there... (once again, i'm not explaining my claims, but i don't feel i need to. it's my opinion) -joshua...