179,854Messages
9,130Senders
30Years
342mboxes

← archive index

Re: (idm) Re: The Good Old Days

5 messages · 5 participants · spans 1 day · search this subject
◇ merged from 2 subjects: (idm) re: the good old days · (idm) the good old days (quantified)
2000-03-12 13:10Kelley Hackett RE: (idm) The Good Old Days (Quantified)
2000-03-12 17:36Massimo (idm) Re: The Good Old Days
2000-03-12 17:52Re: (idm) Re: The Good Old Days
2000-03-12 23:08Brian Gause Re: (idm) Re: The Good Old Days
2000-03-12 23:55Noah Sasso (idm) Re: The Good Old Days
expand allcollapse allclick any summary to toggle that message
2000-03-12 13:10Kelley Hackettha ha....Matt, I like You for some reason......Well said fella... and here is the reason w
From:
Kelley Hackett
To:
,
Cc:
marsel
Date:
Sun, 12 Mar 2000 08:10:16 -0500
Subject:
RE: (idm) The Good Old Days (Quantified)
permalink · <397CA68ABF5AD111863C00805F0DDE980E312C@aba.iupui.edu>
ha ha....Matt, I like You for some reason......Well said fella... and here is the reason why, you gave a solution, at least regarding bringing back some of the older music...and this is what is needed...although the IDM artist have progressed on to different sounds, it doesn't mean that it cant be just as warm, creative, and for a lack of a better term shocking......but yes, it does seem that many artist have not maintained the quality of sound that they previously had...case in point.....John Beltran......Earth & Nightfall, for me, very nice, very nice initial CD(almost from beginning to end).......Placid......So sweet, oh so sweet( and this is what made me REALLY like JB, he did it AGAIN), and then you have 10 Days of Blue........Fantastic, Brilliant, and a sound that no one else really came close to producing....after that well........ As the saying goes, "if isn't broke dont fix it"! I agree with Matt on re-releasing all the older stuff from Detroit and that "Nuron school" as I like to call it.....also, but as well, some artist on the list and off it should try to carry the Music on....sorta like the idea of B12 with Detroit..........as you see, the music now doesn't even compare with the music then(but you do get nice tunes every once in a while).....and this would be the way for say a 4th/5th generation of artists to emerge representing that lush, warm, soulful, melodic and wonderful sound...... And yes, Drift, Row. (and you others over in the UK) tell em, tell em---especially Stasis......dont leave us to this drudgery!!!!!!!!! Sincerely, Hk! -----Original Message----- From: AeOtaku@aol.com [mailto:AeOtaku@aol.com] Sent: Saturday, March 11, 2000 1:12 AM To: idm@hyperreal.org Subject: (idm) The Good Old Days (Quantified) I would say the Good Old Days of IDM probably started with Kraftwerk and Manuel Gottsching and ended with the break up of the Black Dog, but they are definitely concentrated from the time of "Strings of Life" and "Night Drive" to the first albums of B12, As One, Black Dog, etc. before their later work. So about 1987-1993. As always I disagree with the Jet Jaguar about music (I don't think we've ever agreed on anything) and I pretty much hate the later material of Kirk, Carl, Plaid, etc. not so much because of the music itself (which doesn't bother me) but the fact that these guys don't make tracks like "Nebula Variation", "How the West Was Won" or "Scoobs In Columbia" anymore. Now I do realize I can't (and have no right) to tell them what to as artists but I still hate their current material. This is true of just about every producer I liked who has "old" material. It seems in these scene nobody gets better: they just get worse. In reality they get more developed and gather moss down the abstract hill, but I prefer the pure techno sound (and think I am not alone). On another note, someone out there with connections and money: there is an extremely lucrative and ethically rewarding market for legitimate reissues. There have been a lot of people e-mailing me lamenting that these tracks we're speaking so highly of aren't available anymore. One person put it best when they said that it sucks to hear about the greatest IDM tracks to know he'll never get the chance to hear them. Hey, anybody in the UK, talk to B12, talk to Kirk, talk to Nuron, talk to Black Dog, get some clearance and make some nice discography CD's of old singles and reissue some albums and comps. On another note, however, in the past year I have seen all of these available (most not more than once or twice): Everything on A.R.T. Everything on B12 Everything on 100% Pure Everything on Ifach Everything from Black Dog / Plaid Everything on Likemind Everything on Void Everything on Otherworld Virtually everything in the old Detroit scene etc. etc. etc. etc. So for those with time and money and dedication, they still go up out there. But obviously there just aren't enough especially for those who haven't heard the tracks and aren't slamming down months of looking and piles of cash.... Matt --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: idm-unsubscribe@hyperreal.org For additional commands, e-mail: idm-help@hyperreal.org --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: idm-unsubscribe@hyperreal.org For additional commands, e-mail: idm-help@hyperreal.org
2000-03-12 17:36MassimoCaution, incoming rant.... The way I see it, part of the problem is 'genrefication' - give
From:
Massimo
To:
Date:
Sun, 12 Mar 2000 17:36:16 -0000
Subject:
(idm) Re: The Good Old Days
permalink · <002501bf8c4c$93f3e120$e0094ad4@holger>
Caution, incoming rant.... The way I see it, part of the problem is 'genrefication' - give something a name/label and it becomes easier to stop seeing what's possible; just follow the rules and wahay you have a 'house' track, a 'jungle' track....an 'idm' track. Yeuch! There is a lot of this going on - this is partly why so many 'idm' releases are disappointing. This is why 'drum n' bass' was the victim of it's own success. Words are useful, just don't believe the hype. What was/is nice about groups like Black Dog and Autechre is individuality, personality, uniqueness and freedom, more than just style. Arovane? Markant? Gimmik? All talented folks obviously, but perhaps a little blinkered, cynical or in too much awe of their predecessors. Come on guys - be yerselves! Also, it's not really fair to ask artists to keep on making the same music. That would be boring and you'd be doing yourself a disservice too. Naturally many experiments fail, but without them there would be no progress. And sometimes it's hard to spot the successes straight away. I'd like to think that 'idm' (as opposed to 'dim'? - doin-it-for-the-money?) is the music of 'early-adopters' - those that are willing to assimilate new forms and styles, those that relish the unexpected. Please don't get bogged down in how good 'Scoobs' was or some such nonsense. If it's really that bad now then move on to something else, or look harder for what is good and what is emerging. Don't forget - there has always been a lot of crap around, and a lot of great stuff that gets passed over. Of course, the music continues to evolve and outgrow it's pidgeonholes, which can only be a good thing. Personally I think that the words 'Intelligent', 'Dance' and 'Music' are all complete misnomers for what we are talking about here. I would call it something like inovative electronic sound creation if that didn't sound so horribly pretentious. Beware the dreaded genre! IDM is dead. Long live ???
2000-03-12 17:52AeOtaku@aol.comIn a message dated 3/12/00 12:34:19 PM Eastern Standard Time, massimo@pavilion.co.uk write
From:
To:
,
Date:
Sun, 12 Mar 2000 12:52:29 EST
Subject:
Re: (idm) Re: The Good Old Days
permalink · <15.1dac9ca.25fd335d@aol.com>
In a message dated 3/12/00 12:34:19 PM Eastern Standard Time, massimo@pavilion.co.uk writes: << Also, it's not really fair to ask artists to keep on making the same music >> Yeah, I totally agree, which is what I think I said. I was just pointing out that I much prefer the old material, as I think most other hardcore fans of this genre do. It's fine that they keep making new releases in many genres as long as I have the old releases to spin. Matt --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: idm-unsubscribe@hyperreal.org For additional commands, e-mail: idm-help@hyperreal.org
2000-03-12 23:08Brian GauseAll, This is an interesting argument that crops up again and again. I have a feeling even
From:
Brian Gause
To:
Date:
Sun, 12 Mar 2000 15:08:30 -0800
Subject:
Re: (idm) Re: The Good Old Days
permalink · <38CC236E.FED5AF97@us.oracle.com>
All, This is an interesting argument that crops up again and again. I have a feeling even the ancient Greeks were doing this. "Yeah, that Homer...he just can't tell a story like he used to." We used to do it here about RDJ a few years ago. It goes on and on. On the surface, this is about the music...but this argument is never about the music. It's about your own changing tastes and reminiscent ideas about "the good old days". Think, for a minute, about your parents. Do they listen to new music or do they still listen to the same music they listened to twenty years ago? This attitude, that things are getting worse somehow (in music, society, politics, etc) is what leads to the so-called generation gap. If you get stuck in 88-89 detroit, you'll never see the beauty of mille plateaux 2000 or something else five years down the line. Sure, Incunabula was a landmark album for sean and rob, but they're artists and they're changing. Some of it works for me, some doesn't...but you have to understand that an album (or a music) doesn't exist in a vacuum. The reason an album is beautiful or brilliant is, in part, because of what it's being compared to. This means that time and place play a crucial role in understanding and taste (taste being the integration of your own understanding...however that works)... so, if you never grow out of 89 detroit, you're tastes will never change. If you never accept that it might get better than it used to be, you will stop growing. It's not about the BEST music because music can't be quantified like this. I can't help but think of Picasso. He was ridiculed at every turn and there's still a huge portion of the public who think his blue period was his best work. Maybe, maybe not...but to stop there is missing out on about 50 years of his work. This seems disappointing beyond words. There have been some interesting points in this thread, but it seems simple enough to me...when you stop looking for new stuff, you stop growing. And, for me, this is what happened to my parents. That's a path I'm not taking. ---brian AeOtaku@aol.com wrote:
quoted 17 lines In a message dated 3/12/00 12:34:19 PM Eastern Standard Time,> In a message dated 3/12/00 12:34:19 PM Eastern Standard Time, > massimo@pavilion.co.uk writes: > > << > Also, it's not really fair to ask artists to keep on making the same music >> > > Yeah, I totally agree, which is what I think I said. > I was just pointing out that I much prefer the old > material, as I think most other hardcore fans of this > genre do. It's fine that they keep making new releases > in many genres as long as I have the old releases to spin. > > Matt > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- > To unsubscribe, e-mail: idm-unsubscribe@hyperreal.org > For additional commands, e-mail: idm-help@hyperreal.org
-- Save the whales. Collect the whole set. Trade them with your friends. Brian Gause Technical Writer Applications Division Oracle Corporation (650) 506-1311 bgause@us.oracle.com The statements and opinions expressed here are my own and do not necessarily represent those of Oracle Corporation. --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: idm-unsubscribe@hyperreal.org For additional commands, e-mail: idm-help@hyperreal.org
2000-03-12 23:55Noah Sasso>The way I see it, part of the problem is 'genrefication' - give = >something a name/label
From:
Noah Sasso
To:
Date:
Sun, 12 Mar 2000 18:55:43 -0500
Subject:
(idm) Re: The Good Old Days
permalink · <000801bf8c7e$7a7f6340$d55ce88c@alligator.clarku.edu>
quoted 11 lines The way I see it, part of the problem is 'genrefication' - give =>The way I see it, part of the problem is 'genrefication' - give = >something a name/label and it becomes easier to stop seeing what's = >possible; just follow the rules and wahay you have a 'house' track, a = >'jungle' track....an 'idm' track. Yeuch! There is a lot of this going on = >- this is partly why so many 'idm' releases are disappointing. This is = >why 'drum n' bass' was the victim of it's own success. Words are useful, = >just don't believe the hype. What was/is nice about groups like Black = >Dog and Autechre is individuality, personality, uniqueness and freedom, = >more than just style. Arovane? Markant? Gimmik? All talented folks = >obviously, but perhaps a little blinkered, cynical or in too much awe of = >their predecessors. Come on guys - be yerselves!
Guess I'll chime in here and say that I agree %100.. your entire post was so on-point, I barely have anything to say. =) Seems like most people bend themselves to fit into genres, rather than bending the genres to fit themselves. Or maybe most people have such limited vision that they just really want to sound like their heroes? the other problem with genrefication is that the people who do bend the rules of the genre tend to get ignored by most, as there is a plethora of easier to swallow stuff out there .. bah humbug. maybe it's a good thing that all the music in every genre is starting to sound the same. :( noah --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: idm-unsubscribe@hyperreal.org For additional commands, e-mail: idm-help@hyperreal.org