179,854Messages
9,130Senders
30Years
342mboxes

← archive index

(idm) request for comments: labels, genre, sub-genre, pigeonholes

1 message · 1 participant · spans 1 day · search this subject
1996-07-12 00:02Mark Kolmar (idm) request for comments: labels, genre, sub-genre, pigeonholes
expand allcollapse allclick any summary to toggle that message
1996-07-12 00:02Mark KolmarOK, let's try this again. Please comment, make suggestions... Can anyone suggest labels an
From:
Mark Kolmar
To:
IDM List
Date:
Thu, 11 Jul 1996 19:02:10 -0500 (CDT)
Subject:
(idm) request for comments: labels, genre, sub-genre, pigeonholes
permalink · <Pine.PTX.3.93.960711183424.4911A-100000@ccs1.ccs.nslsilus.org>
OK, let's try this again. Please comment, make suggestions... Can anyone suggest labels and/or artists who incorporate elements of IDM, along with other styles, but in the end can't be pinned down to a specific genre? I'm asking both to find music I might enjoy, as well as to get suggestions for where to send my own material. For example: ClockDVA, Download, Meat Beat Manifesto, etc. Do current industrial and IDM/techno meet at a clear boundary, or is there some kind of murky DMZ in-between? What elements of the IDM sound are absolutely essential? If you toss traditional harmony and melody out the window, is it something else and no longer IDM? If the "I" is for "Intelligent" and the "D" is for "Dance", then something like Jeff Mills' "Growth" EP is better-qualified to my ears than anything by FSOL, for example. I also count the first track on AFX's AB4 among my favorites in the style, and I already know what most of you think about that record. --Mark
quoted 1 line>>>
I do not understand the ongoing squabbles about genre-boundaries, which take place on almost any mailing list or newsgroup you care to name. Perhaps someone would care to explain. Personally, I find categories only useful as rough reference points, and see the musical spectrum as a multi-dimensional continuum without boundaries. <<<