Hi Greg,
quoted 7 lines I don't think you're right in using an all encompassing word such as
>> I don't think you're right in using an all encompassing word such as
>> "Techno" ... Kraftwerk were doing their best stuff around the time of the
>> Sex Pistols, i.e., 20 years ago and what else would you call it but Techno!
>
>I wouldn't call their old work "Techno", it's more like "Electronic" that
>is the roots of what we *now know today* as "Techno". I was using the term
>"Techno" in the current-day (context, context (-: ) vernacular.
Didn't they or YMO actually coin the phrase... "techno"!?
quoted 5 lines Basically I don't think it's evolved rapidly at all. Progressed yes, with
>> Basically I don't think it's evolved rapidly at all. Progressed yes, with
>> all its little off shoots, but not evolved so rapidly.
>
>I think grabbing Kraftwerk as a singularity and using that as a basis for
>your evaluation is specious at best.
Definitely not a singularity... YMO, AON, Yello and the likes spring to mind
freely.
quoted 5 lines I stand by my claim. There have been times in the past 5 years where the
>I stand by my claim. There have been times in the past 5 years where the
>music of time N was already "obsolete" by the time N+6 months. I've never
>seen such a fast period of change in musical genres like that. The music
>of 1996 doesn't remotely sound like the music of 1991 to my ears. 1991-1992
>Techno music almost sounds "quaint" now.
Music only becomes obsolete for the trendy, fashion, trainspotters amongst
the idm community. 1991-92 2 of my all-time favourite tracks were released
PNG and Didgeridoo. Neither sound dated to this pair of ears.
quoted 3 lines Again, a specious comparison. Why compare it against the people who are
>Again, a specious comparison. Why compare it against the people who are
>*deliberately* trying to do something which is a re-creation/evolution of
>that which came before it, i.e. Nuevo Electro?
Maybe, but why do it again... one reason is that it was good and they want
to go back and find the 'goodness' in it. You don't do that to things that
are obsolete... do you?
Regards,
John
/-------------------------------------------------------------------\
| JOHN BUS (aka. JOHNNY TURBO) |
| SNAIL - Digital Access Records |
| PO Box 1838 Macquarie 2113 Australia |
| EMAIL - John.Bus@syd.dcet.csiro.au |
\-------------------------------------------------------------------/