--- Adam Piontek <damek@earthling.net> wrote:
From: <edhall@weirdnoise.com>
<<Describe it any way that seems suitable, but calling
it a "bad release" or "garbage" crosses the line into
telling other people what they should think of it.>>
Crossing a line? Telling your honest opinion is
sufficient. It doesn't have to be watered down to
please others. If you think it's meadow muffin than
say it.
quoted 2 lines but reviews are inherently subjective. this has
> but reviews are inherently subjective. this has
> been covered already. who doesn't know this?
You would think this is totally obvious. But there are
several morons on this list that can't bare the
thought of someone not liking what they like.
Truthful opinions, PLEASE.
If you hate something, say so, maybe say something to
support your feelings...like the production quality is
shite, or whatever.
quoted 4 lines do i have to put smileys and "IMHO" after every damn
> do i have to put smileys and "IMHO" after every damn
> thing i type now? if i call something "bad" and
> "garbage" isn't it obvious that that's only what i
> think?
You would think that people are grown up enough to
discuss difference of opinions on this list. But after
the whole PLUR thread, I may be proven wrong
quoted 9 lines if i said "this is objectively a bad release with no
> if i said "this is objectively a bad release with no
> technical skills
> or merit, the artist should be lynched, no one
> should buy it, and
> people who even have an mp3 of it should be given
> severe wedgies" --
> then i might agree with you that i was telling other
> people what they
> should think.
Not a bad idea. Wedgies for supporting bad electronic
music, I like that. But then there would be a
significant number of bowlegged ravers.
quoted 3 lines but if i say "this is bad and garbage" ... um, i
> but if i say "this is bad and garbage" ... um, i
> didn't tell anyone
> anything except what _i_ think.
Agreed, fuck all the spineless sheep on this list. Be
honest about your opinions!
__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Photos -- now, 100 FREE prints!
http://photos.yahoo.com
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: idm-unsubscribe@hyperreal.org
For additional commands, e-mail: idm-help@hyperreal.org